The television community again crosses its fingers this
month, hoping that the annual Upfront ad-buying
market remains strong despite another year of debate
over the relative effectiveness of TV advertising.
Meanwhile, proponents of in-store media are
hopeful that the rollout of a television network inside
Tesco, the U.K.'s largest grocer, will jumpstart the
prospects of retail narrowcasting as a legitimate ad
buy here in the U.S.
Industry pundits have been drawing the curtain on
TV advertising for several years now. (They've done
the same in the past with print and radio, and those
shows still haven't closed either.) And futurists have
been promising the era of in-store TV for nearly a
decade. (Wal-Mart aside, there haven't been many
supporters.)
Could this finally be the year when marketers
admit that TV advertising is no longer effective enough
to serve as the primary marketing tool? Might we
finally see significant progress in developing the retail
environment as an alternative advertising conduit?
Well, yeah, maybe. The evidence is still too
insufficient to go ahead and schedule the revolution.
But there have been a few recent signs:
- What has been a steady decline in TV viewership
for any one program or any single network this year
turned into the alarming defection of an entire
demographic group. Now where do you go to reach
18-to-34-year-old males? Even network NBC has
decided that Best Buy might be
a logical place
to find them.
- Tesco is admired as a retail innovator, so its
rollout of a
major narrowcasting program is a big deal.
Kroger, for example, currently is in the process of
overhauling its loyalty-card program to emulate what
the British chain has done in that area. Food retailers
might view Tesco's TV initiative as a similar
bellwether.
- Reports that another U.S. TV conglomerate plans
to
fund installation of an in-store TV network as a
promotional vehicle for its programming could be the
most significant step yet. If advertisers outside the
retail world start viewing the store as an effective
marketing medium -- and would be willing to help
eliminate the cost prohibitions that have kept many
retailers from jumping in -- the revolution might very
well be upon us.
In-store media historically has been regarded as
detrimental to display merchandising. That's because
funding for these tactics usually comes from the same
below-the-line marketing coffers, and not from
advertising budgets. If the aforementioned initiatives
continue, both the perception and the reality should
change.
But that either-or debate has been counterintuitive
all along, as results from another recent U.K. trial
attest: In measuring the effectiveness of a
dynamic
digital signage network (another tactic long in the
development process), convenience-store operator
Spar found that ads were "most effective" when the
products being promoted were displayed "conveniently
close" to the TV screens.
Media, in any form, can only do so much on its
own.
As always, we encourage your feedback and
welcome your support.
Sincerely,
Peter Breen
Managing Director, Content
Click here for more information. »
|